Construction cost is only part of the church project budget
Thursday, January 02, 2014
The task of preparing to build a new church facility may seem overwhelming to the steering committee. There is much to do and much to plan. However, with experienced professional help, the task can be accomplished.
When getting ready to build, one of the first questions is: How much is all this going to cost? It is important to remember that the construction cost of the building is only part of the overall expense. Constructing the building is the largest single expense, but there are a number of other significant costs that are essential and should not be underestimated.
In this article, we will briefly summarize the major items that make up a project budget. At the end of this article is a checklist to help with preparing such a budget.
Purchasing property will be one of the first big expenses. The cost of purchasing land, including any expenses or financing costs, must be included in the project budget. Omit it from the budget only if the land is already owned, free and clear. If the church leadership is not sure whether more land is needed, ask an experienced architect or land planner for advice. A site feasibility study or master site plan will help to determine the need for more land.
Most church leaders or steering committees are not in a position to estimate construction costs on their own. The help and advice of your architect or your contractor will be essential. One of the architect's duties should be to help make early projections of construction costs based on the size and type of building needed. This may take place long before a contractor is selected. At this stage the estimate is normally based on average costs per square foot of similar projects in the same region of the country.
Sometimes preliminary cost projections must be made years before the project is actually built. Inflation must be allowed for in to all cost projections, especially those based on historic cost data. Similar projects built in the same vicinity more than three years ago may not be reliable indicators of cost because of inflation and changing market conditions. Projects built during a recession do not make good cost examples later on during an economic boom.
Projects used for comparison should have inflation factored in if they are to be relied upon. Prior to the start of the Great Recession in 2008, construction inflation often exceeded 5 percent per year over the previous 20 years. It was relatively flat from 2008 to 2012 and then began to rise again. Construction inflation can vary widely from year to year.
Site construction cost should always be calculated separately from the building. Every site is different. Hilly sites cost more to develop than flat sites. There is a great variation in local and regional requirements for such things as landscaping, storm drainage, paving, curbs and grading.
The site construction cost will be the most difficult item to estimate until site engineering documents can be priced by the contractor. Even then the cost could depend on the time of year, with projects starting in late fall or early winter costing a little more due to weather conditions.
Construction cost is defined in the construction industry as the contract cost paid to a contractor or contractors, for construction of all portions of the building and site (for material, labor, overhead and profit). In some cases it may involve a single general contractor or a construction manager, and in a few cases there may be multiple contractors and suppliers. Construction cost is only part of the total cost of the project and may be less than 70 percent of project budget.
Almost all church building projects of any size will require the services of experts whose experience and training qualifies them to provide professional design services. Architects and engineers are essential to the process. Trying to get along without help from these professionals is probably the biggest mistake any church could make.
Design fees will depend to a great extent on the size and complexity of the project and on the firm selected. Never make the mistake of selecting the architect based on low fee. It is not the purpose here to deal with the topic of how to select the architect or what to expect design fees to cost.
For preliminary project budgeting purposes, it is best to estimate design fees as a percentage of the construction cost. This does not necessarily mean that a percentage fee is the only way architects establish their fees. Many architects will use a fixed fee or an hourly fee with a maximum.
Architectural fees vary by region. Services of structural, mechanical and electrical engineers are almost always included in the architect’s fee. Civil design (site engineering) is sometimes treated as a separate fee. Most architects who work with churches will incorporate civil engineering into their fee for basic services. Verify that your architect includes civil engineering.
In addition to professional fees, most architects and engineers also charge for various reimbursable expenses. This includes travel expenses, automobile mileage, printing and delivery expenses for construction documents. Sometimes renderings, models and computer animations are treated as expense items.
Expenses are related to project size and travel distance for the professional. It is normal for expenses to be invoiced as a separate line item, different than professional fees. Most architects mark up reimbursable expenses 10 percent to 15 percent. Ask the architect for an estimate of expenses.
There are several costs that are in the same category as design expenses except they are usually handled separately from architectural fees. These are normally directly paid for by the owner (the church) and do not generally go through the architect.
Most projects will require the services of a professional land surveyor to prepare a complete site conditions survey, including boundary and topography. The cost of this survey will depend on the size of the property being surveyed, the density of the vegetation and the severity of the topography (change of elevation). Important things to look for on the survey include the presence of floodplains, streams, wetlands, utility easements and other conditions that may impact the usability of the site.
Subsurface investigations are usually recommended by the architect or the structural or the civil engineer. Soil borings will reveal the structural qualities of the ground on which the building will sit. Soil permeability tests are done when a septic system is required because of unavailability of sewer.
There are several types of environmental investigations. These are sometimes required by the lender or by the local government. Site environmental investigations, also called a "Phase 1 Investigation," look for hazardous materials that may be buried on the site. Existing buildings requiring renovation can contain hazardous materials such as asbestos and lead paint. These require testing to verify their presence.
All of these situations require specially-trained environmental engineers to investigate for the presence of hazardous substances and recommend methods of removal or remediation. If hazardous materials are found, it can turn into a major expense. Some sites may also require investigation for historic artifacts, burial grounds, endangered species or other environmental concerns.
Furniture, Fixtures and Equipment (FF&E)
A new building would be unusable without furnishings. Churches need worship seating, classroom chairs, tables, kitchen equipment, audio and video equipment, and many other items for proper functioning of the facility. The project budget at the end of this article has a checklist of items that may need to be included in the budget. It lists several items that might not have been considered such as new choir robes, hymn books and liturgical furnishings.
FF&E are not always included in building construction cost, because they are not usually part of the work of the general contractor. They are listed as NIC (not in the contract). A general contractor usually does not want to be responsible for ordering pews, chancel furnishings or expensive sound equipment. Rely on the advice of your architect and interior designer when budgeting for furniture, fixtures and equipment.
Sometimes churches prefer that some of the work be performed by member volunteers. This is not always a good idea, especially if church members do not have the necessary skills and experience. Some churches will have members who are skilled craftsmen or subcontractors and prefer to have these people perform some of the work.
if any work is to be member-provided, the cost of this work may be budgeted as a separate line item. The checklist gives a general idea of the types of things churches can handle as separate contracts and which can sometimes save the church money.
Every construction project has necessary changes. The contingency fund is there to pay for essential changes to the work. It is there to cover the cost of things that come up that you have no choice but to do.
For example, if the fire marshal visits the job and requires more exit signs (even after having approved the plans), you have no choice but to add the items he requires. If the engineer discovers that a structural component needs to be modified, then it must be done. If during the work, unforeseen conditions such as rock or poor soils are encountered, then the contingency fund will come in handy.
Contingency funds are not for upgrades. If the church leadership wants to upgrade the carpet or have better light fixtures, the money for these should not come out of the contingency fund. The contingency fund is not there to use if the bids come in over budget. Establish the amount as a percentage of the final construction contract cost and use it only for essential changes. The checklist includes suggestions on how much the contingency fund should be for various types of projects.
Financing and Fundraising
The cost of financing should be calculated into the overall long-term cost. After all, it may take many years to pay off a loan, and the interest alone can represent a significant portion of overall cost. Today, most churches try to keep long-term borrowing to a minimum, but even then there will be expenses associated with short-term loans. Talk to several lenders for help in calculating financing and interest cost. Include closing costs and fees.
Most churches will also need the expert assistance of a fundraiser or capital stewardship consultant. These specialists can more than pay for their expense by providing advice and help that will significantly increase the amount that members pledge to the building fund. Consult with several professional fund raisers to obtain estimates of their fees and expenses and include this in the budget.
It is critical that the church understands the total cost of the project can be 20 percent to 30 percent more than the construction cost alone. Preparation of a complete and accurate total project budget is important and will require experienced professional assistance. The budget should be regularly updated throughout the planning and design process. Working with your architect, and use the checklist that follows to get started establishing the project budget.
Project Budget Checklist
1. Land purchase
2. Site conditions survey — topographic, boundary and tree location
3. Subsurface soil investigations
4. Environmental and hazardous material survey
5. Design, engineering fees and expenses
- Architect and engineer fees and expenses
- Civil engineer, landscape design fee*
- Interior design fee*
- Renderings, models, computer animations*
- Audio, video, lighting and acoustical consultants*
- Special lighting or production lighting consultant*
6. Building construction cost — amount paid to general contractor
7. Site construction cost — amount paid to site work contractor or general contractor for site construction
8. Other costs
- Church monument sign and interior/exterior directional signage**
- Sewer lines, water mains and other utility lines — off-site
- Development impact fees, plan review fees, building inspection fees, special inspection fees, development and building permits**
- Rezoning expenses
- Professional fees (architect or attorney) associated with rezoning, special use permit, waivers and variances
- Bonds and insurance**
- Builder's risk insurance**
- Owner's liability insurance
- Other legal fees and expenses
9. Contingency fund for essential changes during construction (as a percent of construction cost)
- 2-5 percent for new construction
- 4-8 percent for additions
- 7-15 percent for building renovations
10. Furniture, fixtures and equipment (FF&E)
- Seating for worship space, chancel/platform furnishings, altar railing
- Stained glass windows or other decorative art
- Audio, video and special lighting (AVL) equipment
- Kitchen appliances and equipment**
- Chairs and tables for fellowship hall and classrooms
- Media center — library shelving and equipment**
- Office furniture and equipment
- Recreation equipment — indoor
- Recreation equipment and playground equipment — outdoor
- Nursery cribs and preschool furnishings & play equipment
- Man lifts or portable scaffolding for maintenance access to high ceilings
- Choir and ecclesiastical robes, paraments, liturgical items and banners
- Hymn books, pew bibles, prayer books, communion items
- Musical instruments, music stands, piano, organ, etc.
- Baptistry — portable or nonbuilt-in type
11. Work by either owner or contractor
- Folding partitions and operable walls**
- Window treatments, blinds or curtains**
- Landscaping, irrigation, fencing and other minor site work**
- Demolition — interior or exterior**
- Painting or other finishing work, tile, stone, wall coverings, etc.**
- Minor repairs and renovations to existing buildings**
12. Financing (interest, closing costs and fees)
- Construction loan
- Permanent loan
13. Fundraising expenses
- Fees paid to capitol stewardship consultant
- Expenses for publicity, brochure printing, banquets, etc.
14. Moving expenses for churches that are relocating
*Some architectural firms may include these items in their fees and expenses.
**May be built into construction contract cost or not in contract.
- Interior design is not about flowers
- Emerging green building material technologies to watch
- Window film improves building system performance
- Watch out for these 3 common electrical safety hazards
- 3-D printing is revolutionizing construction and design fields
- Indoor lighting and its effect on emotions
- How to stand out in your next meeting
- Common mistakes that lead to adhesion failure
- How the partial government shutdown affects federal contractors and the economy
- Allow yourself to set — and get — higher fees
- ADA partners with PBS Kids to make sure children are ready for the dentist
- How ready is your capture?
- Palm Beach Atlantic’s Tracy Peyton named 2019 Ron Balicki Scholarship recipient
See your work in future editions
Your content, Your Expertise,
Your Industry Needs YOUR Expert Voice & We've got the platform you needFind Out How