Survey: Employee incentives don’t align with their preferences
| April 16, 2021
It’s important for employers to show appreciation for their workers. However, a recent survey reveals that many organizations are missing the mark in terms of incentives and rewards.
Blackhawk’s “Employee Appreciation Survey,” conducted online in January 2021, reveals the following:
Employees want to be celebrated
- 80% of employees believe that it is important for employers to celebrate workplace accomplishments, anniversaries, and achievements.
- 86% of employees want their employer to express appreciation for their personal contributions.
Not all companies have recognition and incentive programs
“The biggest mistake employers are making today is in not offering rewards and incentives to their employees,” says Betty Weinkle, director of partnerships at Blackhawk Network. “We learned that more than 40% of our respondents’ employers do not offer incentives/rewards or formally recognize their human capital.”’
What employees want doesn’t align with what they’re offered
When comparing the types of incentives that the surveyed employees would like to receive with the types of incentives they’re actually receiving, there’s a broad disconnect:
- 66% of employees want bonuses; only 28% say they receive them
- 42% of employees would like time off work; only 15% say their company grants it
- 41% of employees prefer prepaid or gift cards; only 20% agree their company awards them
- 33% of employees want personalized cards or emails; only 25% say they receive them
Interestingly, only 19% of employees are interested in being singled out at a company event or ceremony; however, a higher percentage (27%) are recognized this way.
The issue of timing
Survey respondents also said how long it takes to receive their reward would determine its impact. However, opinions vary on what’s actually considered too long:
- 22% felt that more than a month is too long
- 23% thought a month is too long
- 24% considered two weeks to be too long
- 24% listed a week as being too long
- 7% believe a day is too long
Tips for showing appreciation for employees
One of the biggest mistakes that employees make in showing appreciation for their workers is the same mistake that most people make: Giving people what you like (or you think they “should” like), instead of giving them what they actually want.
This is why some men who enjoy receiving power tools for Father’s Day don’t understand that some women may not appreciate receiving appliances for Mother’s Day. Those of us who tend to celebrate with food may not understand people who don’t think every occasion calls for food.
At many organizations, the people handling rewards and incentives are making decisions based on their personal preferences. For example, at one organization, I remember someone suggesting that an employee’s birthday should be considered an additional vacation day. Many of the employees loved this idea. But the people in charge of making these decisions voted the idea down because they said they would want to spend their birthday surrounded by colleagues. Obviously, they didn’t understand that it wasn’t about them.
The same organization would have elaborate, formal banquets (requiring dress attire) to recognize workers — even though the feedback indicated a significant portion of the workers hated these events. Again, the decision-makers chose these events based on their preferences. Many of them stated that they liked to don gowns and tuxedos and considered the banquets their favorite event of the year.
If you’re going to reward and incentivize employees, take the time to find out what they want. This should be done anonymously to avoid putting undue pressure on workers to respond a certain way.
“We recommend employers take care to adopt incentive practices that are meaningful to their workforce, but don’t create additional administrative burden,” Weinkle says. “Prepaid and gift cards are a perfect way to achieve this because they are highly desirable, easy to disburse, and can also be offered digitally.”
Blackhawk’s research found that employees now place as much value on digital cards as they do physical cards. This popularity has been fueled by COVID-19, which resulted in a dramatic increase in online shopping.
Whether you choose a physical or an online card, make sure that it’s general enough to appeal to all workers. For example, a Starbucks gift card might not appeal to someone who doesn’t drink coffee, and a Home Depot or Lowe’s gift card might not appeal to those who wouldn’t normally shop there.
And since bonuses and time off were the top two responses among surveyed employees, it’s worth considering how to work these options into your company’s budget.
- Mental health during the holidays: Tips for a brighter season
- How to plan your holiday office party without (cookie) cutting corners
- How health care professionals can prevent needlestick injuries
- 7 gifts your customers want this holiday season